Germany: GmbH shares versus AG shares
A German GmbH (the most common startup legal form) issues Geschäftsanteile, which are shares in a private limited company but are transferred by notarised deed, making transfers slower and more formal than in a UK company. A German AG (public limited company, more common for later-stage or IPO-track companies) issues Stückaktien, no-par-value shares that can be transferred more like listed company shares, which matters for companies planning to move toward structures such as growth shares later.
The notarisation requirement for GmbH share transfers is a distinctive German feature. It adds cost and time to every share transfer, including employee share transactions, which is one reason German startups often prefer virtual instruments like phantom shares for employees instead of real GmbH shares.
France: actions ordinaires
French startups, usually structured as an SAS (société par actions simplifiée), issue actions ordinaires with flexible rights set out in the company's bylaws (statuts). The SAS structure gives founders significant freedom to design share rights and governance compared to more rigid company forms.
Ordinary Shares at a glance
| Country | Common startup entity | Ordinary share term | Transfer formality |
|---|---|---|---|
| UK | Private limited company (Ltd) | Ordinary shares | Stock transfer form, board approval |
| Germany | GmbH | Geschäftsanteile | Notarised deed required |
| Netherlands | B.V. | Gewone aandelen | Notarial deed required |
| France | SAS | Actions ordinaires | Transfer order, registered in share account |
Ordinary shares, questions by country
- Can ordinary shares have no voting rights?
- Yes, in flexible regimes like the UK, Netherlands and France, companies can create non-voting ordinary share classes, often used for employee holdings.
- Why do German startups use phantom shares more than other countries?
- The notarisation requirement for GmbH share transfers adds cost and delay, so many German startups prefer virtual, contract-based instruments for employees instead of issuing real shares.
General information for founders, not legal or tax advice. Thresholds and rates change, so confirm the current position with an adviser in the relevant country before granting.